The holidays are coming: parties, champagne toasts, dinners with friends and family. They're also one of the busiest times of the year for law enforcement cracking down on drunk driving. Whether you're celebrating in League City or anywhere else in Galveston County, I get the same questions about DWI every year, and a lot of them start with something that isn't true.
Here are eight DWI myths and what the law actually says.
Myth 1: "I wasn't driving, so it can't be a DWI."
Texas Penal Code Section 49.04 defines driving while intoxicated as operating a motor vehicle in a public place while intoxicated. Notice it doesn't say driving. It says operating.
We get cases where a client went to sleep in a parking lot after drinking at a bar and got woken up by an officer at 3 or 4 in the morning. It was cold, so the person turned the car on. They never moved it. But if you're in the driver's seat, your foot's on the brake and the car is on, officers are probably going to believe that's operating. There's no clear definition of operating under Texas law. It comes down to what a juror's common sense tells them.
Myth 2: "A parking lot isn't a public place."
If the general public has access to it, like a turnoff from a public road, it's going to be considered a public place, even a private lot of a business that's closed.
Your own land is different. If you're driving on your own property behind a locked gate, that's not a public place, and it's not a violation of 49.04. It could be some other offense, especially if there's a wreck, but it's not a DWI.
Myth 3: "I'm under 0.08, so I'm fine."
Intoxicated means not having the normal use of your mental or physical faculties due to alcohol, drugs or some other substance, or having a blood or breath alcohol concentration of 0.08 or higher. It's not only a number.
People pull up a calculator, or even ask AI: here's my height, my weight, what I'm planning to eat and drink, what will my alcohol level be? That doesn't settle it. If you're not a regular drinker, one glass of champagne can affect your mental faculties. My mom hardly ever drank, but every now and then on New Year's she'd have one glass of champagne and start acting funny. A prosecutor can use that kind of buzz to argue you lost the normal use of your faculties.
And at 0.15 or higher, the charge becomes a Class A misdemeanor DWI, with up to a year in jail and up to a $4,000 fine.
Myth 4: "No-refusal means I can't refuse a test."
Many counties in Texas declare a no-refusal period during high-risk holidays like New Year's Eve. It doesn't mean you can't refuse a breath test or a blood test. It means that if you refuse, the police have a judge and a prosecutor available to write a warrant, get it reviewed and signed, and force you to give a sample of your blood. On a night like New Year's Eve, they're getting search warrants all night long.
A warrant lets an officer have your blood drawn at a hospital, at the jail, anywhere there's a phlebotomist. If you try to resist the blood draw, they're going to add a resisting arrest charge. Now a Class B DWI comes with a Class A resisting arrest.
Myth 5: "If I drink water or eat something, my number will stay down."
Drinking water afterward is fine, but none of that is going to affect your alcohol level. What affects the alcohol coming into your system is the amount of alcohol that goes into your mouth. Drink less, or don't drink at all if you're concerned about this.
Myth 6: "A first DWI means three days in jail no matter what."
The statute does say a first DWI carries a minimum of 3 days up to 180 days in jail. It's one of the only Class B misdemeanors with a minimum jail sentence. But that 3 days can be worked around.
The jail gives two-for-one credit for each day you've been there. If you've been in jail for one hour of a day, they count it as a day, and over the course of two days you might end up with four days of credit. The prosecutor can later award you credit for that time. If a probation agreement is reached, you can avoid the 3 days by probating a longer sentence. And if we get the case dismissed, you're not serving any jail time.
Here's the strange part: for the Class A, 0.15 or higher, the legislature didn't include the minimum 3 days. It's zero to a year. They're not perfect.
Myth 7: "If I ask for a lawyer, the investigation stops."
If you tell the officer you want to talk to a lawyer before answering any questions, he's not going to let you call one. He's going to go through his process, and you decide whether to participate. You either put evidence on video, like the one-leg stand and the walk-and-turn, for a jury to analyze, or you refuse and the jury gets to consider that you refused.
If you refuse everything, you're still pretty likely to get arrested and they'll probably go for a warrant, but it limits the evidence they have. We call that a total refusal case. The downside is you're probably not going to get a pretrial diversion, a special type of probation that ends in a dismissal, because the DA has to approve it, and they'll hold the total refusal against you. Maybe that's not fair, but they will. The way we win a total refusal case is at trial, or by showing the prosecutor they can't prove it.
Whatever you do, don't apologize to the officer for being intoxicated. That's a death knell for your case.
Myth 8: "If police knock on my door, I have to answer."
If you've already made it home and someone called in, you don't have to answer the door. Police can break down a door for a felony arrest warrant or a search warrant, but not for a misdemeanor arrest warrant.
If an officer calls you or shows up at your door and you don't know what it's about, the only words you should say are: "Thank you, officer. Can I get your name and number? My attorney will give you a call." Don't confirm your name, your date of birth, where you live or where you were last night. The first answers out of your mouth are the ones they need to prove their case.
The bottom line
The simplest way to avoid a DWI this holiday season is not to drink and operate your vehicle. Have a ride lined up, and download a rideshare app before you go out. An Uber or a hotel room is a lot cheaper than a DWI.
This post is for educational purposes only and is not legal advice.