Galveston · Galveston County · League City · Texas City · Friendswood · Brazoria CountyGalveston County · League City · Texas City

Family violence cases move fast. One night there's an argument at home in La Marque, somebody calls 911, and by morning there's an arrest, a protective order and a court date. Most of the people I talk to in that situation have heard a lot of advice from friends and family. A lot of it is wrong, and some of it makes the case worse.

Here are six myths I hear all the time about assault family member charges, and what's actually true.

Myth 1: "If she drops the charges, the case goes away"

This is the biggest one. The person listed as the victim doesn't control the case. The State does.

The State typically consults the listed victim to see if they want to pursue prosecution. But even if the victim declines, the case can still go forward, often with specialized prosecutors handling it. The State can keep prosecuting you, and try to put you in jail, even after it receives an affidavit from the victim asking to "drop the charges."

That's because these cases get built on objective evidence: the 911 call and how people sound on it, photos, marks and bruises. Prosecutors are supposed to look at the case objectively and ask what it would look like in front of a jury. Their job isn't to win every case; it's to seek justice. But a lot of what leads to the arrest in the first place is someone's word, and that's where the defense starts.

Myth 2: "There was no real injury, so there's no case"

To prove assault, the State has to show you intentionally, knowingly or recklessly caused bodily injury to the person listed as the victim. Bodily injury means any physical pain or impairment of physical condition. A scratch on the arm or a red mark on the leg can lead to a conviction.

An assault family member charge is usually a Class A misdemeanor, with a punishment range of up to 365 days in jail and up to a $4,000 fine. Family assault covers people who are dating, married, roommates or family members, and prosecutors often treat these cases more seriously than a regular assault.

Myth 3: "I'm innocent, so I'll just explain my side"

Telling your story to the police won't stop an arrest. It will be used later. Even if you are totally innocent and you know it, do not talk to a police officer before you've talked to an attorney.

Here's why it's so dangerous in family violence cases. The first person to call police is the one most likely to be listed as the victim. We get cases all the time where our client was just the second person to call about the same incident, and our client got charged.

If an officer wants to talk to you and you don't know what it's about, the only words you should say are: "Thank you, officer. Let me get your name and phone number so my lawyer can call you back." If an officer calls and asks you to come down to the station for a few questions, you are probably the subject of an investigation. Don't go without a lawyer.

And remember: your silence can't be used against you. If you say you don't want to talk, that can't even be played in front of the jury. The only thing that can happen when an innocent person talks to the police is that they say something that makes them look like they're not innocent.

Myth 4: "They can't kick me out of my house before I'm found guilty"

They can. A protective order can kick you out of your own home for 61 days on a misdemeanor, or 91 days on a felony involving a deadly weapon. It can keep you from talking with your spouse. People ask, "I haven't been found guilty yet. Can the judge do this?" The courts have consistently held that these protective orders are valid.

On top of that, judges regularly set a no-contact order as a bond condition. A bond condition lasts for the entire life of the case, not just 61 or 91 days. If you text, call or have any communication with the person listed as the victim, you can end up back in jail with a new Class A misdemeanor for violating a protective order or bond condition. We can petition to remove or modify these orders, but until a judge does, follow them.

Myth 5: "If I take deferred, it's like it never happened"

Not for family violence. If you're convicted of an assault involving family violence, or you plead guilty to deferred adjudication probation, a second assault family member charge can be enhanced to a third-degree felony. That's 2 to 10 years in prison and up to a $10,000 fine. Only a true dismissal keeps a family violence charge from being used to enhance a future case.

Myth 6: "I'll just get it sealed later"

A nondisclosure can seal certain misdemeanor convictions that ended in straight probation. But one of the requirements is that it can't be a family violence offense. That door is closed. The way to protect your record is to fight the case now, toward a dismissal, not to plan on sealing it later.

The bottom line

An assault family member arrest in La Marque is serious from the first hour: a protective order, bond conditions, a Class A charge and a record that can turn the next accusation into a felony. Don't rely on the victim dropping the charges, don't try to explain your way out, and follow every order while we fight the case.

This post is for educational purposes only and is not legal advice.

Speak With a Galveston Criminal Defense Attorney Today


Free, confidential consultation with former prosecutors, led by a Board Certified criminal defense attorney.

(409) 877-4909