Galveston DWI Lawyer - The One Leg Stand Field Sobriety Test
If you’ve ever been pulled over and asked to perform field sobriety tests, you’ve likely encountered the one-leg stand test. One of the three commonly used tests for assessing potential intoxication (along with the Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus (HGN) test and the Walk-and-Turn test), the one-leg stand test is a key tool that officers use when evaluating if a driver is under the influence of alcohol.
At Galveston Criminal Defense and DWI Attorneys PLLC, we often work with clients who face charges stemming from these tests. As Brian Foley, a DWI attorney, we’re breaking down what the one-leg stand test is, how it works, and why it can sometimes be misleading. Let’s dive into the details.
Galveston DWI Lawyer - The One Leg Stand Field Sobriety Test
The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) developed the one-leg stand test back in the 1970s as part of a set of standardized field sobriety tests. NHTSA’s goal was to create reliable ways for officers to evaluate a person’s impairment during traffic stops. These tests are designed to identify signs of impairment based on physical clues observed during the test.
The one-leg stand test asks a driver to stand on one leg, hold the other leg about six inches off the ground, and count aloud for 30 seconds. During this time, the officer looks for specific signs or "clues" that indicate intoxication.
The Four Key Clues
During the test, officers are trained to look for four specific clues that may suggest a driver is impaired:
Placing the foot down prematurely: If you put your foot down before completing the 30 seconds (unless instructed to), that’s considered a clue.
Using your arms for balance: Officers will instruct you to keep your arms by your sides. If your arms move more than six inches away from your body, this can be seen as using them for balance.
Swaying while balancing: This clue is an observation of your ability to maintain balance while standing on one leg. If you sway noticeably, it’s noted as a clue.
Hopping: If you hop to maintain balance instead of standing still, this will also be considered a clue.
What’s Important to Know About the One-Leg Stand Test
While the test can provide clues, it’s important to remember that it’s not foolproof. Many factors can impact how well someone performs this test, and a failure to perfectly complete the task doesn’t necessarily mean a person is intoxicated.
For instance, hopping is the least common clue to appear in these tests. While officers may mark it as an issue, people with medical conditions such as ankle or knee injuries, or those who have undergone hip replacements, might have difficulty balancing, regardless of their sobriety. It's worth noting that these physical impairments don’t equate to intoxication.
Additionally, not everyone who struggles with balance issues is necessarily under the influence of alcohol. Some people simply have difficulty with balance due to various health conditions.
The Role of Video Evidence
At Galveston Criminal Defense and DWI Attorneys, we’ve seen thousands of DWI videos. While some believe that blood or breath tests are the most crucial evidence in a case, we argue that the most important piece of evidence is often the video. When the jury watches the video of the field sobriety tests, they will use their life experience to determine whether the person looks intoxicated.
It’s possible to place your foot down after only 25 seconds, rather than the 30 seconds requested. This minor slip-up might be marked as a clue by the officer, but to the jury, it could look like someone who is simply trying their best to perform the test, rather than someone who is visibly intoxicated. In some cases, minor errors in performance can even help a defendant appear more sober, especially if they can maintain balance in a way that doesn't appear to be influenced by alcohol.
What Officers and Drivers Need to Know
For officers conducting the test, it’s essential to give clear, concise instructions. If you repeatedly explain the test or confuse the individual with back-and-forth instructions, it can undermine the reliability of the results. A poor test performance due to unclear instructions doesn’t reflect well on the officer or the driver.
As for those who find themselves facing a DWI charge, it's crucial to consult with an experienced attorney who can evaluate the circumstances of your case. An attorney can assess the validity of the field sobriety tests, the arrest, and all the evidence—helping you develop a strong defense strategy. Medical issues, physical conditions, or even stress from being pulled over can all impact how you perform on these tests. A knowledgeable lawyer can ensure your rights are protected.
Conclusion
While the one-leg stand test is an important tool for officers in assessing sobriety, it’s not always a clear-cut indicator of intoxication. Numerous factors can affect a person’s ability to balance, and a failure to perform the test flawlessly doesn’t mean a person is drunk.
Whether you're a driver facing DWI charges or an officer administering the test, it’s important to understand the nuances of the one-leg stand test and its limitations. As always, if you’re facing DWI charges, don't hesitate to reach out to a skilled attorney who can guide you through the legal process.
If you're interested in learning more or need assistance, feel free to contact Brian Foley at Galveston Criminal Defense and DWI Attorneys PLLC. And if you found this post helpful, don't forget to like, subscribe, and ring the bell for more insightful content on your legal rights and field sobriety tests. Thanks for reading!
Comments